Socialism is not just about slogans and posturing. Socialists have to govern well and in fact they have to govern much better than conservatives due to the imposed ideological stigma.
And when I say “socialism”, I’m not talking about seizing the means of production, simply a return to New Deal reforms that somewhat leveled the playing field between capital and labor. But even these sort of policies would be greeted with shrieks of Communism, Communism, Communism, thanks to decades of pro-capitalist propaganda.

I’ve been thinking about all of this in the wake of the recent primary elections that brought an influx of Democratic Socialist of America (DSA) candidates. Their dilemma is that they will have to learn how to govern in a socialist way while operating in a hostile neoliberal environment. Then there’s that wee problem that the left has been out of power for so long that the muscles of competent governance have atrophied alarmingly.
Democrats and Republicans, since Reagan, have largely refused to compete on doing things for ordinary Americans, especially when it comes to economic policies. Politics has consisted of cultural war bullshit, with the Red Team pushing guns, God and abortion while Team Blue obsesses over identity politics. Policies center on subsidizing banks and corporations, with the idea that money should be given to rich people and programs which help ordinary Americans are simply impossible.
Presently the US maintains a social order in which public resources, state subsidies, collective labor, and technological infrastructures are privatized and redirected toward the enrichment of billionaires. Even though the United States possesses more wealth than any society in human history, and can afford universal healthcare, modern rail systems, affordable housing, renewable energy, rebuilt cities, and first-class public education, it simply chooses not to.

That’s an opportunity for socialists. Neoliberalism’s insistence that we can’t have nice things is bad politics, because a government that makes people’s lives worse is less popular than a government that makes people’s lives better. Since the US is a duopoly and you only get to vote for two options, neither of which intend to help, the only solution is to change the nature of one of the parties. Hence the efforts by socialists to take over the Democratic Party.
What seems obvious in the wake of the two Trump election victories is that the fascist-right can only be stopped in the long term by radically transforming our economic system, with changes that give all working people a shot at a stable, middle-class life. If progressives hope to build the durable majoritarian coalitions needed to make that happen, they will have to deliver concrete material benefits to working people’s lives, so ordinary Americans will once again feel that their lives are equal or better than their parents’ were.
But to do any of this the newly elected socialists are going to have to relearn how to actually govern. Serendipitously, Matt Stoller has an amazing article on his site Big, talking about the nuts and bolts of governance. Matt says that not only have leftists lost the historical knowledge of how to govern but that conservatives have actively sabotaged competent government as a key component of their takeover. Conservatives, after all, have run on government-bad since forever, then when in power they make it so.
“From 1995-2007, the GOP held the U.S. House of Representatives, and continued to strip out internal capacity. President Bill Clinton and Gingrich cooperated on the “Reinventing Government” initiative, to privatize many executive branch functions. Large numbers of regulatory agencies willingly gave up authority, knowledge, and staff.
And the culture changed, as the Democratic Party and liberal elites became dependent on the Clinton White House. The West Wing created a template for the Democratic insider, which was someone who pretended to be nerdy and detail-oriented, but was in fact just a political operative with an Ivy League degree. Pretty soon, the only way anyone could think about governing was through the lens of deference to fake experts, whether economist, pollster, or corporate lawyer...Anyone who knew anything about governance, and wanted to act using public power, was perceived to be some sort of dirty hippie loser.”

Newly elected Democratic Socialist or leftist officials will face a daunting task of navigating a hostile political, economic and media landscape, where the Democrats are as much the enemy as the Republicans.
Update: Democratic Socialist, Seattle councilwoman, Kshama Sawant, explains what they will be up against. “Also, one of the tactics that the Democratic Party uses when you’re in elected office, and I experience this every single day, is it’s like being in a Mean Girls episode. They ostracize you socially. They try to make you feel like you’re isolated, that you are not welcome, all of that. And it is so crucial, because without this we cannot win, it is absolutely fundamentally crucial that the leadership of the working-class movement be completely clear. This is not about you. You are not there to make friends. You are not there to have a comfortable workday. No. The whole point is that if you are fighting for the working class in the halls of the power of capitalism, which is what a city council or US Congress is. They don’t exist to give working-class people better lives. These are institutions of the capitalist state. They exist to defend capitalist interests and so when you go there, you are not going there among colleagues. You are going there and the people who sit next to you are your class enemies. You are there to fight for the working class. And so, you have to be unbowed and unbroken in the face of all of this. And these are not exaggerations. This is exactly what it looks like. And it takes what I did, what we did, in order to win against the Democratic and Republican parties.”
She continues–“…the Democratic Party goes to absolute war against you if you dare to fight for the working class. And that is the whole point. If you are fighting for the working class, you will become enemy number one of the Democratic Party. So, it is up to you if you want to be a leader of the working class, then you have to embrace that enemy number one status as something that is necessary. And in fact, as I said, as a badge of honor.”





























