I was primed to be part of the professional/managerial/class like my parents. As a teenager I worked at a large amusement park, where they made me a manager. I enjoyed it and was good at it but soon came to the realization that a mid-level manager was capital’s henchman in an economy that was exploitive and cruel.

It’s only gotten way, way worse. Presently, across the political spectrum, Americans are anxious from concerns about the cost of living, precarious employment, and the dominance of monopolies in retail, tech, big-Pharma, and finance. This affordability combined with powerlessness is a crucial feature of our current political climate. This is manifested as alienation or Conspicuous Despair, and it’s clear that Americans are fed up with the ideological defenses of low wages and bad options for work, housing, and health.
Our lived reality is that a small class of billionaire capitalists has consolidated an extractive economy to a degree that excludes a large portion of society from the productive economy. And the professional/managerial/class, or symbolic capitalists, were there every step of the way as allies, while they gave us “woke” cultural war bull-shit in lieu of class politics. Politics in the US has only served capital for decades. All policies were to squeeze as much wealth out of society. It started with moving factories for low cost labor, now we have a new word: enshitification, there’s the gig economy. And all of it is extractive rather than productive. This is coming to a head as things get worse and worse for the majority of Americans, because the cultural wars can only mask those deep-seated economic anxieties for so long.

Last week The Nation praised what they described as a “progressive insurgency” sweeping the US, caused by worsening economic immiseration, state tyranny, and the reactionary political culture.
But, there’s a problem.
“The truth is a two- edged sword, James Baldwin argued, “and if one is not willing to be pierced by the sword, even to the extreme of dying on it, then all of one’s intellectual activity is a masturbatory delusion and a wicked and dangerous fraud.”
This quote comes from an essay by Musa al-Gharbi, who wrote “We Have Never Been Woke”. He reminds us that working-class Americans view the professional/managerial/class or symbolic capitalists with justifiable suspicion. “To the extent that less affluent, less educated, less urban, less secular and less liberal Americans believe that institutions symbolic capitalists control do not well represent or serve people like them – they think we look down on them, we don’t exert much effort to understand what they want or how they think, they don’t have much voice or a stake in the symbolic economy as it currently operates, many policies that may be good for “us” are not good for the industries and communities they are part of – this is not “misinformation.” It’s true. Others mistrust and resent us, in part, because they correctly perceive some bleak realities about the prevailing social order that most of “us” decline to reckon with.
U.S. symbolic capitalists are excellent at extracting resources from the wealthy and corporations in the name of helping working people – we do it here better than almost anywhere else. However, we tend to be much less effective at actually giving the captured assets to the people we’re ostensibly trying to help or listening to the stakeholders we’re supposed to be representing.”
Intellectual honesty is what Baldwin was talking about and sociologist al-Gharbi brings it forward to put the onus on the professional/managerial/class or symbolic capitalists to explain the situation the US finds itself in. That ‘s not the story that you will read about in the New York Times. This is not surprising. Every empire in history has responded to the crisis of elite malfeasance by blaming the victims. It’s always the character rather than the structure. It’s the only available move for the propertied class, because the alternative explanations implicate the billionaires and their symbolic capitalists apparatchiks.

What’s even worse is that the symbolic capitalists collusion with capital contributed mightily towards the election of Trump, who is the ultimate representation of the triumph of the extractive economy at the expense of the productive one. The PR term for this looting operation is “shareholder capitalism”. Meanwhile symbolic capitalists still don’t get Trump’s appeal because they’ve never met Americans from flyover states whose livelihoods, marriages, communities, and futures were destroyed because of their self-serving behavior. I can’t prove it but my working theory is that to cover their betrayal, symbolic capitalists seized upon Russia-gate as an excuse.
The sword of intellectual honesty needs to pierce both ways. If America has any chance of reform the professional/managerial/class, symbolic capitalist apparatchiks will have to take responsibility for their actions and repent. They will have to cease their collaboration with the billionaires.
The political reality facing us is that the power of capital must be curtailed before reforms have any chance to be enacted.






























